911爆料

What sorts of nudges win wallet share in the attention economy?

Body

Nudges鈥攖he subtle interventions that encourage people to make beneficial decisions without forcing them into these choices鈥攁re a popular marketing tool widely used for a variety of social causes and business purposes.

Siddharth Bhattacharya, assistant professor of information systems and operations management at the Costello College of Business. Photo by Jeffrey Porovich/Costello College of Business

But their effectiveness depends on finding the right combination of context and content, says , an assistant professor of information systems and operations management at 911爆料's .

His recently published paper in  focuses on revenue-based lending (RBL), an emerging financing option whereby repayments to investors come as a percentage of future revenue. It studies how a real-life peer-to-peer RBL platform based in South Korea improved both investor engagement and borrower outcomes through the strategic use of nudges. 

The paper was co-authored by Sunghun Chung from George Washington University, Chul Ho Lee from Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, and Subodha Kumar from Temple University.

The RBL platform that participated in this randomized controlled trial had more than 25,000 registered investors who had lent $210 million to more than 6,000 businesses, as of January 2022. 鈥淭he platform caters to SMEs and small businesses looking for funds, which involves a certain amount of risk for the investor. RBL adds an extra element of risk, because the investor returns are directly based on the investee鈥檚 financial performance,鈥� Bhattacharya says.

During an eight-week period (Nov 2021 to Jan 2022), the platform sent different nudging messages designed by the researchers to investors who had previously opted into SMS marketing messages.

The experiment involved four text-message variants (i.e., nudges) in total, designed to push very different psychological buttons. The researchers compared these with a plain message and a hold-out group that received no message.

One appealed to altruism, reminding investors that their loans would be a 鈥渂ig help for many people.鈥� Another leaned on competition, encouraging recipients to 鈥渂eat 80 percent of Korean adults鈥� in making wise investment decisions.

The other two nudges were more about encouraging investors to follow through on their intentions, stressing ease and convenience (鈥淲ith just a few clicks, you can invest鈥�) and precommitment (鈥淎chieve your financial goal over the next five years鈥�).

Mainly, the researchers evaluated the relative performance of nudges in terms of their impact on the borrower. But because RBL ties investor returns to borrower revenue, it was really about what benefited both players in this two-sided economy. 

鈥淲e were measuring whether these nudges made the system more resilient to short-term pitfalls like liquidity loss, etc.,鈥� states Bhattacharya.

Bhattacharya and his co-authors found that the altruism and competition-based nudges had negligible impact, producing roughly the same outcomes as plain messages. However, the ease-and-convenience and precommitment nudges resulted in significantly improved capital flow, reduced delinquency and shortened payoff durations for SMEs.

Investors who received the latter two nudges were more active and engaged on the platform, making quicker decisions and signing in more often. This translated to a heavier and steadier flow of funds to the platform鈥檚 SMEs.

A similar pattern emerged in an online U.S.-based study where 338 participants were exposed to the same nudging treatments, reinforcing the findings from the South Korea experiment.

The results of the follow-up study also indicated that the ease-and-convenience and precommitment messages resonated because they directly addressed the sense of mental 鈥渙verwhelm鈥� that often stops us from doing things we would like to do. 鈥淓ase-and-convenience reduces the cognitive overload and shows that this is very easy to do, and that makes people want to execute that job right away,鈥� he says. 鈥淭he other mental obstacle is procrastination. But if you remind people of their goals through precommitment, that can motivate them.鈥�

He suggests that in the peer-to-peer RBL context, financial commitment raises the stakes beyond the point where messaging appealing to altruism or competitive status would be effective. This is a possible explanation for the findings, rather than a mechanism directly established by the experiments. 鈥淭his is different from other nudging studies dealing with education or selecting between different products or food items, in that people are putting in their own money,鈥� Bhattacharya says. 

These findings fit neatly alongside Bhattacharya鈥檚 previous research on the  and the negative impact of  for philanthropy chatbots. Together, they bolster the implication that to win wallet share in the attention economy, nudges and other forms of real-time messaging should try to clear away mental clutter, not add to it with gauzy emotional appeals.

鈥淧eople have so many things going on these days,鈥� Bhattacharya says. 鈥淭heir attention span is smaller. They鈥檙e burdened with multiple things at the same time. This creates mental inertia, and the nudge should be like a gentle push to help you overcome it.鈥�

Nikki Kazimova contributed to this article.